(813) 963-7600
14741 N Dale Mabry Highway, Tampa, FL 33618
Location Button, Italian Restaurant in Carrollwood, FL

Italian Restaurant in Tampa, Florida

Order Now Button, Italian Restaurant in Carrollwood, FL
Discounts, Italian Restaurant in Carrollwood, FL
Alternate Website Button, Italian Restaurant in Carrollwood, FL
Special Offers, Italian Restaurant in Carrollwood, FL

Pizza & More

Make Best New York Pizza your top choice for lunch or dinner. We offer Real New York Pizza and Italian food. All of our menu items are made with fresh, natural ingredients and served just the way you like them.

Customer Reviews

Our customers are raving about our delicious food and friendly service. Check out some of our customer reviews to see for yourself. 
Visit our restaurant in Tampa (Carrollwood), Florida, or contact us to learn more about our amazing menu options.

Best New York Pizza Was Featured in an Article in the Tampa Tribune

About Us

Best NY Pizza is a family-owned-and-operated New York Pizza and Italian restaurant with two locations located in Carrollwood and Wesley Chapel, Florida . We offer a beautiful relaxing atmoshere with delicious menu items for the entire family. Our menu includes absolutely the BEST New York Pizza, Calzones, Rolls, Wings, Calamari, salads, pasta dishes, Canolies and so much more. Convenient dine-in or take-out services are available.

Our Italian restaurant has been in business for more than eight years. We have a large dining room that can seat small families and large parties. Call us at (813) 963-7600 to inquire about reserving a table for your next business meeting or large event. We have big screen HD TVs in the Fast Casual dining area of our restaurant. In our Full Service Dining Room we have a 114 inch HD TV and a Digital Player Baby Grand Piano making Best New York Pizza a fun and relaxing place to be.

Hours of Operation
Sunday–Thursday, 11:00 a.m.–9:00 p.m.
Friday & Saturday, 11:00 a.m.–10:00 p.m.


Debit Cash